Cryoburn | |||||
Lois McMaster Bujold | |||||
Narrated by Grover Gardner, unabridged | |||||
Blackstone Audio, 10 hours, 33 minutes | |||||
A review by Nicki Gerlach
Miles, who has a personal stake in the matter, having been through cryo-preservation and revival once himself,
has been sent by Emperor Gregor to attend a cryonics conference on Kibou-daini, both to learn about the new
technology, and to investigate a company who is looking to expand their business to Komarr. The conference
is attacked by a radical group of anti-cryonics dissenters, but Miles escapes from his would-be kidnappers
only to find himself heavily drugged and lost in the cryo-storage catacombs. He's rescued by Gene, an
eleven-year-old boy who has been living as a runaway ever since his mother, another political dissenter, was
frozen under suspicious circumstances a year and a half ago. Miles didn't want anyone else to become embroiled
in the current mess, but in attempting to do right by Gene, Miles uncovers evidence that points to a potential
planetary takeover scheme... and something even more sinister going on right there on Kibou-daini.
Taken on its own merits, Cryoburn is a solid, engaging conspiracy thriller. It builds its mystery well,
has plenty of action, interesting, sympathetic characters, and keeps everything moving along at a good
clip. However, viewed through the lens of the rest of the Vorkosigan Saga, Cryoburn is
somewhat of a let-down on several fronts.
I think the most obvious of these is its very ability to stand on its own merits. Readers that have stuck
around through the fourteen previous books in the series have not done so because Lois McMaster Bujold can write solid,
engaging conspiracy thrillers, but because we love the characters she's created, and want to spend more time
with them... preferably while they're in the midst of solid, engaging conspiracy thrillers. This book takes
place roughly six years after Diplomatic Immunity; Miles and Ekaterin now have four kids, and are in
completely different places in their lives. But because most of the conflict in Cryoburn is external
rather than interpersonal, (and because all we see of Ekaterin and the kids is one short vid message from
home), I came out of the book feeling somewhat shortchanged, like there were a lot of interesting stories
and bits of character development on which I was missing out.
This was particularly brought home by the abruptness of the ending. I don't want to give away too many
spoilers, but while I can see the reasons behind why Bujold handled the ending the way she did, I felt like
was important enough to merit more space on the page than it got.
Not that Cryoburn didn't have its redeeming features. I thought Gene was an excellent character, and
enjoyed his POV chapters more than I thought I would, given his non-Vorkosigan status. (My childhood
Zoobooks-loving heart also went out to him and his menagerie and his supply of biology-related trivia.) I
also really enjoyed how Bujold used the premise of cryonics to bring up attitudes towards death and dying,
particularly from Miles, who has already died once, and is further coming to grips with his own mortality as he grows up.
So, while this was an enjoyable listening experience, with nothing actually wrong with it, it just didn't
have enough of what I wanted to be completely satisfying. In a way, I'm very lucky that I came to the
series late (and in their audio format -- Grover Gardner will forever be the voice of Miles in my head);
if I had been forced to wait the eight years after Diplomatic Immunity for Cryoburn to be
published, I think I'd be even more dissatisfied with its lack of connection to what's come before. Now
that I'm caught up, though, I can only hope that it's not another eight years before we get another novel
starring Miles and (hopefully) the rest of the Vorkosigan clan; I've hugely enjoyed having them be
such a large part of my reading life for the past few years. So, if you'll excuse me, I'll be off
starting again at the beginning...
Nicki Gerlach is a mad scientist by day and an avid reader the rest of the time. More of her book reviews can be found at her blog, fyreflybooks.wordpress.com/. |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide