|
I spent Friday evening watching television -- four hours of television -- part of Andromeda,
part of Stargate SG-1, Enterprise, and two episodes of
Battlestar Galactica. During the more than one hour of commercials, I had time to wash the
dishes, balance my checkbook, and answer my mail.
Of the four programs, only one, Enterprise, was more fun than washing the dishes.
Unbeknownst to me, the Sci-Fi Channel kicked its schedule up a half hour, to
make room for a Battlestar Galactica special, so I missed the first half of
Andromeda. I missed the last half of Stargate SG-1 in order to change
channels and watch Enterprise. Since I did not see all of either one, I won't
officially review them, but I do have a few comments.
The people in Andromeda and Stargate SG-1 do not act like people. For one
thing, they are eager, they fall over each other, to sacrifice their lives
to save others. Human beings really do give their lives for others, but
they are not eager to do so. Human beings also have a hefty leaven of
pettiness and selfishness, and it is only in contrast with these less
admirable traits that our rare willingness to sacrifice ourselves stands
out.
The people in Andromeda and Stargate SG-1 do not talk like people. Dialogue
in drama need not be realistic, but it must convey some human quality. In
particular, "cute" dialogue coming from the lips of people who have no reason
to be cute is grating, as are clichés that are meant to be inspiring.
"Everything that happens has a purpose."
Of the two, Andromeda has a lot more going for it -- clumsy but sometimes
charming. It was with relief that I missed the last half of Stargate SG-1.
Star Trek Enterprise, "Daedalus" (***) by Ken Lazebnik and Michael Bryant
This episode is a serious drama about the inventor of the transporter. The
characters are grounded in their own desires, so any heroism stands out as
exceptional rather than the norm. There is considerable resemblance to the
original series episode "The Ultimate Computer." If anything, the episode
is too character driven, too low key. But it held my interest.
Battlestar Galactica, "33" (***) by Ronald D. Moore
The Cylons jump through hyperspace in pursuit of the Galactica and her "rag
tag fleet" every 33 minutes. The characterization is good. Boxey does not
make an appearance, thank goodness, (though I was glad to see him in the
telemovie). But there are problems with the plot. If you know there is
going to be a crisis every 33 minutes over a period of days, you do not keep
everybody awake the whole time. You work in shifts. And you do not wait
for the Cylons to appear, you jump every 30 minutes. Also, the split story
between the resistance on the home world and the flight of the Galactica,
which is getting farther and farther from the home world, makes for
disjointed narrative. Not bad, but a notch down from Enterprise.
Battlestar Galactica, "Water" (***) by Ronald D. Moore
Again there are major problems with the plot, especially this business of
not being able to identify
Cylon spies. Since one Cylon spy often has sex in a public place, I'm
waiting for someone to catch her with her shirt off. Cylon's spines glow
during sex. "This is your captain speaking. You are ordered to pair off
and have sex with the nearest available crewman, while someone watches your
spine. If you see a glowing spine -- rip it out." Then we have the
discussions between Baltar and his computer-chip Cylon girl friend about
god. The Cylon believes in god -- Baltar doesn't. The plot twists
conveniently support the Cylon's belief. And God is apparently willing to
help out a villain in exchange for his belief. What is that all about?
Smallville will return with new episodes beginning January 26th.
|
|
Copyright © 2005 Rick Norwood
Rick Norwood is a mathematician and writer whose small press publishing house, Manuscript Press, has
published books by Hal Clement, R.A. Lafferty, and Hal Foster.
He is also the editor of Comics Revue Monthly, which publishes such classic
comic strips as Flash Gordon, Sky Masters, Modesty Blaise, Tarzan, Odd
Bodkins, Casey Ruggles, The Phantom, Gasoline Alley, Krazy Kat, Alley Oop, Little Orphan Annie, Barnaby,
Buz Sawyer, and Steve Canyon.
|