Blade of Tyshalle | ||||||||
Matthew Woodring Stover | ||||||||
Del Rey, 736 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by Regina Lynn Preciado
Despite my biblioholism, I only rarely find novels so intense that I must take time-outs to recover, akin to a marathon runner
pausing for a sip of Gatorade before beginning the next mile. Diana Gabaldon's Outlander series required a number of these
light reposes, and so has each of Matthew Woodring Stover's four novels.
With Blade of Tyshalle, Stover returns to the caste-driven future Earth and Studio-exploited Overworld he
introduced in Heroes Die. It's seven or so years after Caine's ultimate sacrifice -- you remember, the one that
should have Made Everything All Better -- and the situation is even worse than it was before. Not that Caine's death was
in vain, but powerful forces at work in both worlds have conspired to put millions of people in danger. And because heroes
die, it seems we have no one left to save them.
Bummer, eh?
Over the course of 700-plus pages, Stover takes us on an adventure steeped in thought-provoking questions of ethics, morality,
the abuse of power, betrayal, love, family, race, class, philosophy, self-respect, ego, politics, entertainment, and
religion. And that's just for starters.
The intellectual blends seamlessly with the physical; I never felt tossed out of the story, or worse, like I'd accidentally
slipped into a textbook instead. That's one of Stover's strengths as a writer -- his characters are so complex and involved
that the Big Questions flow naturally from them, rather than sitting awkwardly on top as the author tries to overlay his
agenda onto the story.
Stover's prose is graphic but not gratuitous, sensual but not sentimental; unlike other writers known for their style, he
doesn't allow his facility with language to overpower his characters or their stories. However, his work is not for the
faint-hearted. Sometimes it becomes downright relentless. I would quote a passage here to show you except that the novel
is so integrated that anything taken out of context becomes almost a parody of itself. Blade of Tyshalle
isn't meant to be divided into pithy one-liners.
While I remained engrossed in the story throughout, I did feel somewhat battered toward the end. Perhaps I shouldn't have
read the whole thing in two days. Perhaps some of my feeling for George R.R.
Martin's novels has leaked into this one, that there aren't enough "up" moments to give me a break from the
torment and turmoil besieging the good guys. On the other hand, I admire Stover's ability to make me feel the novel this deeply.
Regina Lynn Preciado lives in Los Angeles with her dog Jedi. You can see a picture of him. |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
If you find any errors, typos or other stuff worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide