The Best of David Farland: Volume 1 and 2 | ||||||||||||
David Farland | ||||||||||||
DFE, 126KB and 150KB | ||||||||||||
|
A review by Trent Walters
The Nebula-nominated "After a Lean Winter" first appeared in Kevin Anderson's intriguing concept
anthology, Global Dispatches, stories of H.G. Wells' War of the Worlds
as if told by other writers. This story was justly reprinted in David Hartwell's Best SF 2. Wolverton
chose to tell it in the raw style of Jack London in the winter squalls of Alaska amid a group of ice-toughened
trappers and dogs. One trapper bets the others that they wouldn't be able to stand against his beast (this
probably isn't a story for incomparable dog lovers). The narrator's sympathy reaches out and touches the
trapper's beast, more than once. The story's final note is pitch perfect. A writing sample that struck
me as particularly sharp:
"Pierre didn't speak. It must have been eighty below outside, and his jaw was leather-stiff from the cold. His
lips were tinged with blue, and crystals lodged in his brows, eyelashes, and beard."
Of all the stories represented here, the biggest risk taker in terms of philosophical/sociological possibilities
must be "Wheatfields Beyond." For a field that prides itself on the What-if? scenario, the big thought experiments
aren't really as abundant as one might think. A lot of SF tells us what we want to know, which is a shame
because we don't have a chance to reexamine what we think about the universe. Tana Rosen, a criminal psychologist,
witnesses a homeless man getting beaten up by a fat, well-off father. Feeling guilty, the father frames the
derelict by giving himself a small puncture and planting a knife at the crime scene. Tana feels this may
be the best situation for the man as he will get food three times a day and a chance to be rehabilitated
since she's sure she can get off on insanity. The rehabilitation is partially successful. He gets a job
and even gets married, but he feels alien in this world, so off he wanders again. Then catastrophe
strikes. An asteroid hitting the earth creates an ecological disaster which pressures countries to fire
off nuclear weapons in a mad grab for land. Tana is much older now, living in a cave, struggling to cope
with life under these conditions. Meanwhile, in a role reversal, the derelict is doing quite well.
"We Blazed" is one of Farland's more powerful short stories, both imaginatively and literarily. Alexander
Dane is immortal, as is his wife. For some reason, though, his wife had been living since 2023, and Dane
has just arrived, seeking his wife who promised to love him forever. Men of the village have tried to kill
him, but Dane merely heals. However, when he finds Kaitlyn, she's immortal but isn't in love. She is
married to another -- Dane's rival -- with children they'd never had because he'd been so busy with his
rock band. Kaitlyn feigns not knowing him, and they decapitate him, plotting ways to get rid of him
forever. This originally appeared in Peter Beagle's Immortal Unicorn. At first glance, Farland's thwarting
of a direct representation of an immortal unicorn may appear cosmetic, but certain aspects run deep through
the story, heart-wrenchingly painful.
What happens to a young boy born inside a city of all women? "A Rarefied View at Dawn" relates this
narrative. Bann and his best friend are just turning the corner for puberty, and of course it is forbidden
that they give the least hint romantic interest, but the city has more sinister plans in store for Bann. This
very nicely overlays the primary story with injecting testosterone into a chicken to see how it
develops. While the language is a little less felicitous here than in other stories, great moments
abound: "[A]s he held [the young chicken], Bann was delighted to feel its tiny heart kicking like a cricket."
"Siren Song at Midnight" is a hauntingly bleak tale. The government created mermen, called Sirens, to survive
on different planets; however, the governments of the world had not only lost major sea creatures like the
dolphin, tuna and whale, but also plankton, lowering oxygen content and hurting the Sirens both nutritionally
and physiologically. Professor Elegante is caught on video giving explosions to the merpeople and is
sentenced to death. His daughter maintains his innocence and does what she can to reach him. This one's
lyrically written at times, but I'm not sure it could have ended much more hopeless (although there is
one tiny ray of hope in here). The science fictional aspects are still pretty nifty, and the emotions are intense.
According to the material accompanying the story, "My Favorite Christmas" has roots in more autobiographical
material than the other stories. Uncle Ed comes to visit the narrator, who is in high school and less than
thrilled at the prospect of having to entertain the hunchback of Notre Dame. But as their neighbor Kaman
Porter accuses them of selling off his Christmas trees, he learns his family had a lot of impishness and
skeletons in the closet. However, they learn something even more surprising: Ed may not be his uncle.
Duke Gorlois' wife is the object of King Pendragon's attentions in "The Mooncalfe," so much so that the
duke has to flee. The king lays siege, but the duke escapes, stealing the king's armor. However, the duke
begins to exhibit some of the king's less savory behavior toward women. The narrator's mother runs across
a knight who causes her to be literally enflamed with lust for this man who does magic tricks with
candles. Then two children are born: One King Uther Pendragon, the other the narrator with radiant skin
called Mooncalfe. Mooncalfe is a fairy that the mother tries to hide away and heal the radiant skin to
normality by burning the bones of a bishop. When she finds a young man who cannot love her the way she
is, she goes to be healed of her skin's malady and finds her true father and why he did what he
did. While the plot is episodic, the work as a whole is strong; for it challenges the general assumption
of many fantasies and even utilitarian philosophy.
In "Feeding the Feral Children" (not in this collection but sold separately, or it can be found in John
Joseph Adams' The Way of the Wizard) Huang Fa had his horse stolen, so naturally he kills them so
that they do not return. However, these barbarian thieves are children whose teeth filed to points. While
Huang Fa feels some remorse, it is not until he learns that one was the child of a great sorcerer that he
fears. He tries to catch up with another traveling wizard, but a storm stands in his way. This one's
style and description captures well the mood and foreignness of another time and another land. The
suspense is intense. The ending, though, while moving, does not quite feel appropriate in a way that's
hard to define -- in the manner that reminds one of how so many Greek myths end: Yes, if that's what
happened, then that's where it has to end. You feel like crying at an unjust universe, from the lip of a
canyon -- "But why?" -- with only your voice echoing back.
While the short story "On My Way to Paradise" is not included in this pair of collections, this one has to
intrigue after it spawned the novel which became a runner-up to the Philip K. Dick award and third
in the Locus awards for first novels. Of the stories here, this one is the most
imaginatively inventive -- a tale of Latin-American political, virtual reality, gene-mod cyberpunk with
military in hot pursuit. It opens with a strange woman who has lost her hand and wants to grow a new
one. Angelo is a pharmacologist/anesthesiologist/doctor whom she calls on. Flaco, his best friend,
and he suspect she's done something illegal. Maybe she has, for assassins try to kill her and anyone
that tries to aid her. It turns out to be much than they thought.... Although the ending petered,
this one was a fun ride.
Some readers like myself love to see what writers are up to: What are their
preoccupations? themes? motifs? stylistic flares? This pair of collections does the job well. It's actually
cheaper to buy the stories separately, at present, so you may want to choose. Hopefully, Farland will
package these together as a whole to tempt readers into doing more than dabble at his smorgasbord.
Trent Walters teaches science; lives in Honduras; edited poetry at Abyss & Apex; blogs science, SF, education, and literature, etc. at APB; co-instigated Mundane SF (with Geoff Ryman and Julian Todd) culminating in an issue for Interzone; studied SF writing with dozens of major writers and and editors in the field; and has published works in Daily Cabal, Electric Velocipede, Fantasy, Hadley Rille anthologies, LCRW, among others. |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide